Frameworks & control

Manual control

A manual control is a control performed by a person, such as an approval, a reconciliation or the review of a report, rather than by a system that enforces the control automatically. Manual controls allow for judgement but are more prone to human error. An automated control is generally regarded as lower risk, provided the IT general controls are effective.

Source: COSO Internal Control: Integrated Framework (2013), principles 11 and 13 and Limitations; PCAOB AS 2201, paragraph 47; Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025, best practice provision 1.2.3

COSO Internal Control: Integrated Framework (2013) describes control activities as a range of manual and automated activities, such as authorisations and approvals, verifications, reconciliations and business performance reviews. Examples of manual controls are the four-eyes principle for a payment, the monthly bank reconciliation and the controller's review of budget variances. Among the limitations of internal control, COSO mentions human error and judgement that can be faulty or biased.

PCAOB AS 2201, the standard for the audit of internal control over financial reporting under SOx 404, lists as a factor in the risk of a control whether it relies on performance by an individual or is automated. An automated control is generally expected to be lower risk if the relevant IT general controls, the general control activities over technology of COSO principle 11, are effective. The competence of the person performing the control and changes in that role also count (paragraph 47). SOx 404 applies only to SEC registrants. Many manual controls rely on a system report; their operation then also depends on the quality of that information, the subject of COSO principle 13.

For the management board, the issue is the mix of manual and automated controls. An application control is built into a system; a manual control depends on the person performing it and on the documentation of that performance. In the annual assessment of design and operation that best practice provision 1.2.3 of the Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025 asks of listed companies, the management board can therefore also consider which manual controls can be automated or supported by Continuous Control Monitoring.

Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a manual control and an application control?

An application control is built into a system and validates, authorises or records transactions automatically, such as an input check or a block on duplicate payments. A manual control is performed by a person; it may rely on system information, but performance and judgement rest with an individual. The reliability of application controls depends in part on the IT general controls.

Are manual controls less reliable than automated ones?

Not by definition. PCAOB AS 2201 regards an automated control as generally lower risk, provided the IT general controls are effective. A manual control is sometimes the appropriate form, for example where an estimate or exception requires judgement. Its risk depends among other things on the competence of the performer and the quality of the information used.

← All terms