Frameworks & control

Key control indicator (KCI)

A key control indicator (KCI) is a measurable value that shows how effectively an important control operates, so that a failure or weakness becomes visible before the likelihood or impact of a risk event increases. A KCI measures control, a key risk indicator (KRI) measures risk exposure and a key performance indicator (KPI) measures performance.

Source: ISACA Glossary (key control indicator; key risk indicator; key performance indicator); BCBS, Revisions to the principles for the sound management of operational risk (2021), paragraphs 35 and 43; COSO Internal Control: Integrated Framework (2013), principle 16; IIA Statement of Position Three Lines Model (2026); IIA Global Internal Audit Standards 2024 (Standard 9.5); Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025, best practice provision 1.2.3

ISACA, the publisher of COBIT, describes a KCI as a measure of the effectiveness of controls that indicates a failure or weakness which may increase the likelihood or impact of risk events. Examples are the number of reconciliations not performed on time, the number of exceptions without follow-up or the number of access rights not yet revoked after an access review.

For banks, the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision describes in its revised principles for operational risk (March 2021, paragraph 35) a framework for the ongoing monitoring and testing of key controls, and metrics that provide early warning on the performance of the business and the control environment. According to the Committee, effective metrics clearly link to the associated risks and controls and are monitored against agreed thresholds or limits. Reports should also include control deficiencies (paragraph 43). In COSO Internal Control: Integrated Framework (2013), KCIs fit the ongoing evaluations of principle 16.

For the management board of a listed company, KCIs provide insight during the year into the operation of the systems, which under best practice provision 1.2.3 of the Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025 it assesses at least annually as the basis for the Statement on Risk Management (Verklaring omtrent Risicobeheersing, VOR). A KCI differs from a KRI, which gives early warning that risk exposure is increasing, and from Continuous Control Monitoring, the automated technique through which KCIs can be measured continuously.

With Optimisation & Assurance Readiness, ONE Risk Advisory helps optimise the control framework and make risk control demonstrably assurance-ready for the board, regulator and external auditor.

Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory

Related service Optimisation & Assurance Readiness

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a KCI and a KRI?

A KRI indicates that a risk is increasing, for example a rising number of complaints or incidents. A KCI indicates that a control is working less well, for example a growing number of overdue controls. Under the ISACA definition such a weakness may increase the likelihood or impact of risk events; a KCI can therefore reveal a cause that later shows up in a KRI.

Who sets up KCIs and who uses them?

The control owners in the first line measure the operation of their controls. The second line monitors and challenges, a role the IIA assigns to the second line in its Statement of Position on the Three Lines Model (July 2026). Internal audit can use KCIs in its risk assessment, but under Standard 9.5 of the Global Internal Audit Standards it documents the basis for relying on the work of others.

← All terms