Control self-assessment (CSA)
A control self-assessment (CSA) is a method in which management and staff themselves identify and assess the risks and controls in their own area, often in workshops facilitated by an auditor or risk manager. A CSA is a self-evaluation by the first line and not an independent review. For operational risk, the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision uses the term risk and control self-assessment (RCSA).
Source: ISACA Glossary (control risk self-assessment); BCBS, Revisions to the principles for the sound management of operational risk (2021), paragraph 35; COSO Internal Control: Integrated Framework (2013), principle 16; PCAOB AS 2201, paragraph 24; IIA Statement of Position Role of the Internal Audit Function in ERM (2026); Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025, best practice provisions 1.2.3 and 1.4.3; IIA Netherlands, Practice Guide VOR en de Internal Auditfunctie (2024)
ISACA describes the method as a joint identification and evaluation of risks and controls by management and staff, possibly with an auditor or risk manager as facilitator. In its revised principles for operational risk (March 2021, paragraph 35), the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision describes self-assessments that evaluate inherent risk, the effectiveness of controls and residual risk, with enough supporting detail for an independent reviewer to see how the ratings were reached. Those principles are addressed to banks.
In COSO Internal Control: Integrated Framework (2013), a CSA can form part of the evaluations through which the organisation ascertains whether the components of internal control are present and functioning (principle 16). PCAOB AS 2201, the standard for the audit of internal control over financial reporting under SOx 404, counts self-assessment programmes among the controls that monitor other controls (paragraph 24); SOx 404 applies only to SEC registrants. For the Statement on Risk Management (Verklaring omtrent Risicobeheersing, VOR) in best practice provision 1.4.3 of the Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025, a CSA can supply the information with which the first line informs the management board about design and operating effectiveness, as described in the 2024 Practice Guide of the Institute of Internal Auditors Netherlands (IIA Netherlands).
Because a CSA is a self-evaluation, it does not provide independent assurance. According to the Basel Committee, comparing internal losses with self-assessments helps to determine whether the process works effectively. Internal audit may facilitate workshops as an advisory service (IIA Statement of Position on ERM, July 2026), but according to the same position it should not be responsible for ongoing risk assessment processes that it later audits. A CSA also differs from a Self-Assessment with Independent Validation, which concerns the quality of the internal audit function.
With Embedding & Transformation, ONE Risk Advisory facilitates risk workshops that involve the first line and create ownership.
Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory
Related service Embedding & Transformation
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a CSA and an RCSA?
For operational risk, the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision speaks of risk and control self-assessments (RCSAs): self-evaluations of inherent risk, control effectiveness and residual risk. A CSA puts the emphasis on the controls. Both are self-evaluations by the first line and not an independent review.
May internal audit facilitate a control self-assessment?
Yes, as an advisory service. The IIA's Statement of Position on the role of internal audit in ERM (July 2026) lists facilitating risk workshops and training as advice. According to that position, however, internal audit should not be responsible for ongoing risk assessment processes that it later audits, and any overlap requires safeguards.
Does a control self-assessment count as support for the Statement on Risk Management (VOR)?
A CSA provides first-line information on design and operation that the management board can use in its annual assessment (best practice provision 1.2.3 of the Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025) and in substantiating the VOR. It is not an independent review. Under part iv of provision 1.4.3, the management board itself determines the level of assurance it gives; the audit committee assesses how the statement is substantiated.