Internal Audit

Audit criteria

Audit criteria are the set of standards against which an auditor evaluates the actual condition of the activity under review, such as policies, procedures, laws and regulations, contracts and recognised frameworks. The gap between criteria and condition is the basis for a finding; without adequate criteria, no well-founded conclusion on the effectiveness of governance, Risk Management and control can be reached.

Source: IIA Global Internal Audit Standards 2024 (Standards 11.3, 13.4 and 14.2); Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025 (provision 1.4.2); IIA Netherlands, regulations on External Quality Assessments (Reglement externe kwaliteitstoetsing, 2024), Article 3

Standard 13.4 of the Global Internal Audit Standards requires internal auditors to identify the most relevant criteria in each assurance engagement. They first assess whether the board and senior management have established adequate criteria; if so, they use them, and if not, they identify appropriate criteria in discussion with the board or senior management. For advisory services, criteria may not be necessary. The guidance lists internal criteria (policies, procedures, KPIs), external criteria (laws, regulations, contracts), authoritative frameworks and standards, established practices and the expectation that follows from the design of a control. The auditor informs management of the criteria in advance and documents the agreed criteria. Under Standard 14.2, a difference between the criteria and the actual condition is a potential finding.

Criteria also matter at a higher level. Under Standard 11.3, a conclusion at the level of the organisation states the criteria used, such as a governance or control framework. Provision 1.4.2 of the Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025 asks the management board to state which frameworks it applied to the design and operation of the internal Risk Management and control systems. For the External Quality Assessment of the internal audit function, the regulations of the Institute of Internal Auditors Netherlands (IIA Netherlands) treat the Code of Ethics and the applicable standards as the criteria.

Audit criteria differ from a control framework, which organises the controls themselves and can serve as criteria, and from risk criteria, which an organisation uses to weigh the significance of a risk. See also Audit finding and Audit scope.

Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory

Frequently asked questions

Who sets the criteria for an audit?

Under Standard 13.4, internal auditors first assess whether the board and senior management have established adequate criteria, for example in policies or procedures; if so, they use those. If the criteria are inadequate, the auditors identify appropriate criteria in discussion with the board or senior management, inform management and document the agreed criteria.

What if there is no policy or standard for the process under review?

Internal auditors then look for appropriate criteria, for example in laws and regulations, a recognised framework or comparable practices, and agree them with the board or senior management. The guidance to Standard 13.4 also mentions recommending that management establish the criteria, or turning the engagement into an advisory service.

What is the difference between audit criteria and risk criteria?

Audit criteria describe the desired state of the activity under review and are the yardstick for an audit. Risk criteria are the yardsticks an organisation uses to assess how significant a risk is. Risk criteria can form part of the audit criteria when the audit assesses Risk Management itself.

← All terms