Professional scepticism (professional skepticism)
Professional scepticism is the professional attitude in which an auditor does not accept information and statements on trust, but questions them, assesses their reliability and seeks additional evidence when information is incomplete or inconsistent. For internal auditors it is a requirement in Standard 4.3 (Professional Skepticism) of the Global Internal Audit Standards; for the external auditor it is required by ISA 200.
Source: IIA Global Internal Audit Standards 2024 (Principle 4, Standards 4.3 and 14.1); IAASB, ISA 200 (paragraphs 13(l), 15, A21 and A22); IAASB, ISA 240 (Revised); NBA, Dutch translation of ISA 220
Standard 4.3 belongs to Principle 4, Exercise Due Professional Care. Internal auditors must, when planning and performing their work, maintain an inquisitive attitude, critically assess the reliability of information, be straightforward and honest when raising concerns and questions about inconsistent information, and seek additional evidence for information and statements that might be incomplete, inconsistent, false or misleading. According to the guidance, the auditor bases judgements on facts, information and logic rather than trust or belief, and seeks evidence for what management asserts. Review by the CAE or a supervisor provides additional validation, and the CAE helps auditors build this competency through training. Standard 14.1 applies the same test when gathering information: is it relevant, reliable and sufficient.
For the external auditor, ISA 200 (paragraph 13(l)) defines the attitude as including a questioning mind, alertness to conditions that may indicate misstatement due to error or fraud, and a critical assessment of audit evidence; paragraph 15 requires it in planning and performing the audit. In its Dutch translation of ISA 220, the Dutch professional body of accountants (NBA) uses the term professioneel-kritische instelling. According to the IAASB, ISA 240 (Revised), effective for audits of periods beginning on or after 15 December 2026, reinforces this attitude in relation to fraud risks.
For the board and audit committee, the difference from distrust matters: the auditor may take past experience of management's integrity into account, but that does not relieve the auditor of the need to obtain persuasive evidence (ISA 200, A22). The attitude also differs from objectivity, the unbiased mindset of Principle 2. See also Independence and objectivity and Audit evidence.
Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory
Frequently asked questions
Is professional scepticism the same as distrust?
No. The auditor does not assume dishonesty, but does not accept information without evidence either. ISA 200 allows the auditor to accept records and documents as genuine unless there is reason to believe otherwise, and states that past experience of management's integrity does not remove the need for persuasive evidence.
What is the difference between professional scepticism and objectivity?
Objectivity (Principle 2 of the Global Internal Audit Standards) is the unbiased mindset with which an auditor forms judgements without undue influence. Professional scepticism (Standard 4.3) is the active questioning and testing of the information itself. An auditor can be objective and still accept a management explanation too quickly; Standard 4.3 addresses exactly that.
How does an internal audit function show that it applies it?
Standard 4.3 gives examples of evidence: workpapers showing how the auditor validated information, documentation that false or misleading information was handled as a finding, workpapers and reports signed off by the supervisor, and records of training completed. An External Quality Assessment looks at those files.