Models & quantification

Scenario analysis

Scenario analysis is a technique that works through the consequences of a coherent set of possible future developments, to see how strategy, results, capital or liquidity hold up under those circumstances. Unlike sensitivity analysis, it changes several risk factors at once and in relation to each other. IEC 31010:2019 describes scenario analysis as a technique for identifying risk.

Source: EBA/GL/2018/04 (Guidelines on institutions' stress testing), paragraphs 9 and 72 to 75; Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35 Article 259(3); Directive 2009/138/EC (Solvency II) Article 45a, inserted by Directive (EU) 2025/2; EBA/GL/2025/04; Dutch Decree on the Financial Assessment Framework for Pension Funds (Besluit financieel toetsingskader pensioenfondsen) Article 23b; IEC 31010:2019 (Annex B.2.5)

For the management board and supervisory board, scenario analysis is a way to discuss uncertainty without committing to a single forecast. A useful scenario is internally consistent: interest rates, the economy, customer behaviour and counterparties move within the same storyline. The EBA Guidelines on institutions' stress testing (EBA/GL/2018/04, applicable since 1 January 2019) make scenario analysis a core part of a bank's stress testing programme. They require scenarios that rest not only on historical events but are also hypothetical and forward-looking, covering different events and levels of severity.

Other sectors have similar rules. Insurers carry out stress tests and scenario analyses where appropriate (Article 259(3) of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35). From 30 January 2027, an insurer assesses in its ORSA whether it has material exposure to climate change risks and, if so, specifies at least two long-term scenarios, one with warming below two degrees Celsius and one significantly above, which it reviews at least every three years (Article 45a of Directive 2009/138/EC, Solvency II). Banks apply the EBA Guidelines on environmental scenario analysis (EBA/GL/2025/04) from 1 January 2027. Dutch pension funds use a uniform set of 10,000 economic scenarios from the Dutch Central Bank (De Nederlandsche Bank, DNB) for scenario analysis (Article 23b of the Decree on the Financial Assessment Framework for Pension Funds).

In the EBA guidelines, scenario analysis is one of the stress testing methods, alongside sensitivity analysis and reverse stress testing. In a broader sense, as with the climate scenarios under Solvency II, it deals with futures that have different outcomes, not only with one severe setback. A Monte Carlo simulation instead draws a large number of random combinations. Through Risk Insight, ONE Risk Advisory uses Enterprise, Process and IT Risk Assessments to map the risks and opportunities that most affect an organisation's objectives.

Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory

Related service Risk Insight

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between scenario analysis and sensitivity analysis?

A sensitivity analysis measures the effect of a change in one or a few risk factors, such as a rise in interest rates. A scenario analysis changes a coherent set of risk factors at once, such as interest rates, growth and defaults within one storyline. The EBA Guidelines on stress testing (EBA/GL/2018/04) make this distinction and ask banks to use the results of sensitivity analyses when selecting scenarios.

Must an insurer include climate scenarios in its ORSA?

From 30 January 2027 it must, if the insurer has material exposure to climate change risks. It then specifies at least two long-term scenarios, one with warming below and one significantly above two degrees Celsius, and analyses their effect at intervals of no more than three years (Solvency II, Article 45a). Small and non-complex insurers are exempt.

← All terms