Models & quantification

Model validation

Model validation is the independent assessment of whether a model is conceptually sound, captures the material risks and produces reliable results in practice. It takes place before first use, after significant changes and periodically thereafter. For the internal models of banks and insurers validation is a legal requirement; backtesting is one of its techniques, not the whole of it.

Source: Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 (CRR) Articles 185, 191 and 325bi; Directive 2009/138/EC (Solvency II) Article 44(5) and Article 124; ECB Guide to internal models (June 2026), Overarching principles, paragraphs 18 to 24, and Credit risk, paragraph 64

For banks with internal models, validation is governed by Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 (CRR). For credit risk models under the internal ratings-based (IRB) approach, Article 185 requires robust systems to validate the accuracy and consistency of rating systems and risk parameters, and a regular comparison of realised default rates with estimated probabilities, updated at least annually. For market risk models, from 1 January 2027 a validation unit separate from the risk control unit must carry out the initial and ongoing validation (Article 325bi). The ECB Guide to internal models (June 2026, non-binding) expects an initial validation followed by an annual one, by a validation function that is independent of model development and has enough qualified staff.

For insurers with an approved internal model, the Risk Management function tests and validates the model (Article 44(5) of Directive 2009/138/EC, Solvency II). Article 124 requires a regular validation cycle that monitors the model's performance, reviews the ongoing appropriateness of its specification and tests its results against experience, including an analysis of stability and of sensitivity to the key assumptions and an assessment of the data used.

For the board and the audit committee, what matters most is whether validation is independent and whether findings are followed up. A validation backlog, models that stay in use without a current validation and open findings without an owner all signal that model risk is larger than it appears. At banks, internal audit reviews the rating systems at least annually (CRR Article 191), is separate from the validation function and, according to the ECB guide, forms its own opinion on that function, its independence and the scope of its work. Model validation is broader than backtesting, which only compares predictions with outcomes.

Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory

Frequently asked questions

Who may validate a model?

Someone who was not involved in its development. The ECB Guide to internal models describes three set-ups: separate units reporting to different members of senior management, separate units reporting to the same member, or separate staff within one unit; large and complex institutions should choose the most robust option. Validation tasks may also be delegated to a third party, within the institution's internal validation guidelines.

How often should a model be validated?

For banks' internal models, the ECB Guide to internal models expects an initial validation, then an annual one, and a new initial validation after material changes or extensions. Solvency II requires insurers to have a regular validation cycle without a fixed interval (Article 124). For other models the frequency belongs in the model risk policy, set according to materiality and complexity.

← All terms