Governance & compliance

Second line

The second line is, in the IIA's Three Lines Model, the set of specialist roles, such as Risk Management, compliance and information security, that support, advise, challenge and monitor the first line. The second line is part of management. It may be organisationally separate from operations, but it does not provide independent assurance; that comes from the third line, the internal audit function.

Source: IIA Statement of Position Three Lines Model (2026); Directive 2013/36/EU (CRD) Article 76(5) and (6); Dutch Decree on Prudential Rules (Besluit prudentiële regels Wft), Article 23b; Directive 2009/138/EC (Solvency II) Article 41(2a), inserted by Directive (EU) 2025/2; Dutch Pensions Act (Pensioenwet) Article 143a; IIA Global Internal Audit Standards 2024 (Standard 7.1)

On 8 July 2026, the IIA replaced its 2020 position paper with the Statement of Position Three Lines Model: Assurance and Advice in Support of Effective Governance. There, the second line is called Support & Specialist Roles. These roles provide expert support, advice, challenge, monitoring and thematic reviews in their specialist area, and strengthen first-line processes through guidance, specialist advice and targeted assurance. The second line reports to a member of senior management or to a board-level committee. The IIA expects enough objectivity for credible challenge of the first line, and notes that reporting through management sometimes impairs it. The model counts support functions such as HR as first line.

In the financial sector, the law takes precedence over this picture. At banks, the heads of the Risk Management and compliance functions are independent senior managers with direct access to the supervisory function, and they cannot be removed without its prior approval (Article 76(5) and (6) of the Capital Requirements Directive, in the Netherlands through Article 23b(2) of the Decree on Prudential Rules since 22 September 2026). Under Solvency II, insurers have key functions including Risk Management, compliance and the actuarial function; from 30 January 2027, Article 41(2a) requires different persons for the key functions, with an exception for small and non-complex insurers or after prior approval, and never in combination with internal audit. Pension funds have a Risk Management function and an actuarial function alongside internal audit (Article 143a of the Dutch Pensions Act, Pensioenwet).

The second line differs from the third line in independence: the internal audit function reports functionally to the board and provides assurance on all lines, including the second. If the internal audit function itself performs second-line tasks, the safeguards described under Combined internal audit and Risk Management function apply. Governance & Control Design by ONE Risk Advisory sets up roles and responsibilities in line with the Three Lines Model.

Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory

Related service Governance & Control Design

Further reading Insurers can no longer combine internal audit from 2027

Frequently asked questions

Does the second line provide assurance?

It provides targeted assurance within its specialist area, but not independent assurance. In its 2026 Statement of Position, the IIA places the second line within management. Independent and objective assurance on governance, Risk Management, compliance and control comes from the third line, which reports functionally to the board.

Who does the second line report to?

According to the IIA, to a member of senior management or to a board-level committee. At banks, direct access of the heads of Risk Management and compliance to the supervisory function is a legal requirement under Article 76(6) of the Capital Requirements Directive. The Dutch Corporate Governance Code 2025 contains no provision on a CRO or a second-line risk function.

May the internal audit function perform second-line tasks?

Under the Global Internal Audit Standards it may, with safeguards: documentation in the charter, acknowledgement by the board and assurance by another independent party over those areas (Standard 7.1). At banks the internal audit function may not be combined with any other function, at pension funds not with another key function, and at insurers under Solvency II not from 30 January 2027.

← All terms