Risk escalation
Risk escalation is the predefined referral of a risk, a limit breach or an accepted risk to a higher decision level when it exceeds the authority or the risk appetite of the lower level. Escalation establishes who must decide and when. It does not shift responsibility for the risk: the owner remains accountable.
Source: FSB, Principles for an Effective Risk Appetite Framework (2013), 4.3; FSB, Guidance on Supervisory Interaction with Financial Institutions on Risk Culture (2014), 3.2; EBA/GL/2021/05; ECB, Aggregated results of the 2025 SREP; Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35, Article 268; Dutch Pensions Act (Pensioenwet), Article 143a; IIA Global Internal Audit Standards 2024 (Standard 11.5); IIA Netherlands, guidance on applying the GIAS in the Dutch two-tier system (2026)
Escalation connects the risk appetite with decision-making. Under the FSB principles for a risk appetite framework (2013), the Chief Risk Officer escalates any material risk limit breach promptly to the board and the CEO. The EBA guidelines on internal governance (EBA/GL/2021/05) require a bank's Risk Management function to report material breaches directly to the management body in its supervisory function, which in the Netherlands is the supervisory board. The FSB's guidance on risk culture (2014) stresses that escalation is not meant to transfer accountability for the underlying issue. In a benchmark of 28 banks, the ECB found in the 2025 SREP that most banks had well-defined escalation processes for limit breaches.
Outside banking, too, legislation lays down escalation lines. At insurers, the key functions operate under the ultimate responsibility of, and report to, the administrative, management or supervisory body, and report major problems promptly (Article 268 of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35). At pension funds, key function holders report material findings to the board, and notify the Dutch Central Bank (DNB) as soon as possible if the board fails to correct in time a substantial risk of breaching a significant statutory requirement or a significant breach of law (Article 143a of the Dutch Pensions Act, Pensioenwet).
Internal audit follows its own route. If management has accepted a risk that exceeds the risk appetite or risk tolerance, the Chief Audit Executive (CAE) discusses it with senior management and escalates it to the board if it is not resolved there (Global Internal Audit Standards, Standard 11.5). According to the guidance of the Institute of Internal Auditors Netherlands (IIA Netherlands) on the Dutch two-tier model, disagreement with management below the management board goes to the management board, and disagreement with the management board goes to the chair of the audit committee.
Governance & Control Design from ONE Risk Advisory designs risk governance models in which decision-making, escalation and reporting lines are clearly assigned.
Last updated: · Editor: ONE Risk Advisory
Related service Governance & Control Design
Frequently asked questions
Does escalation shift responsibility for a risk?
No. Escalation takes the decision to the level that is responsible for it, but the owner of the risk remains responsible for managing it. In its guidance on risk culture (2014), the FSB states that an escalation process is not intended to transfer accountability for the core issue to other individuals or groups.
When does internal audit escalate to the audit committee?
If management has accepted a risk above the risk appetite and the matter is not resolved after discussion with senior management, the CAE escalates to the board (Standard 11.5). In the Dutch two-tier model, according to IIA Netherlands, that means the management board; in case of disagreement with the management board, the matter goes to the chair of the audit committee.
Must a key function holder at a pension fund escalate to DNB?
Under certain conditions, yes. The holders of the key functions for risk control, internal audit and the actuarial function report material findings to the board. If the board does not correct in time a substantial risk of breaching a significant statutory requirement, or a significant breach of law, they notify DNB as soon as possible (Article 143a(3) of the Pensions Act). If the holder is also a board member, they also report to the supervisory board or the visitation committee.