All news
Internal Audit· 15 November 2026 ·8 min read

From 30 January 2027, insurers can no longer combine the internal audit function

From 30 January 2027, an insurer under Solvency II may no longer combine the internal audit function with another key function, even if it is a small and non-complex undertaking. Risk Management, compliance and the actuarial function may still be combined under conditions. Insurers that combine the functions today are best advised to prepare the new set-up now.

A climber on their own rope on a steep rock face at sunset: image by ONE Risk Advisory for the article on the internal audit function at insurers.
Image: ONE Risk Advisory

The revision of Solvency II takes effect on 30 January 2027. Among other things, it brings new requirements for the ORSA, a liquidity Risk Management plan and climate scenarios. It also changes something in the governance of insurers that looks minor at first sight: from that date, the internal audit function may no longer be combined with any other key function. For insurers that combine them today, this calls for a decision by the management board and supervisory board in the coming weeks.

What changes on 30 January 2027?

Until 29 January 2027, Article 271 of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35 applies. Its first paragraph provides that the persons carrying out the internal audit function shall not assume responsibility for any other function. The second paragraph makes an exception: subject to proportionality, the function may be combined with other key functions if this is appropriate to the nature, scale and complexity of the insurer, no conflict of interest arises and separate staffing would impose disproportionate costs. Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/269 deletes that second paragraph with effect from 30 January 2027.

At the same time, the Directive itself gains a new provision: Article 41(2a), inserted by Directive (EU) 2025/2. Insurers appoint different persons to carry out the key functions of Risk Management, actuarial, compliance and internal audit, and each function operates independently of the others. Small and non-complex undertakings, and other insurers with prior approval from the supervisor, may combine Risk Management, the actuarial function and compliance under conditions, with each other or with another function. That flexibility expressly does not extend to internal audit.

De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB), the Dutch supervisor, says the same in its questions and answers on proportionality (in Dutch) of 28 September 2026. DNB also intends to withdraw its 2018 guidance on the proportionate organisation of key functions once the new rules apply.

Does this apply if the Dutch act is not yet in place?

For the internal audit function, yes. Bill 37 007 (the Dutch act implementing the Solvency II amending directive) is before the House of Representatives. The government’s response to the committee report and a memorandum of amendment were published on 9 November 2026; as at 15 November 2026 no plenary debate had been scheduled. A delegated regulation, however, applies directly, without transposition. From 30 January 2027, Article 271(1) therefore applies without the exception, even if the bill is still pending at that time.

How common is this combination?

Not very common, and mainly found at smaller and mid-sized insurers. In its peer review of key functions, published in November 2018 with 2016 as the reference year, the European supervisor EIOPA found that supervisors in 15 countries, including the Netherlands, reported cases where the internal audit function holder also held another key function. They generally described this as rare: in 2016 it concerned less than 5 per cent of insurers in a country. The combination with compliance was the most frequent; no cases were found at large insurers. As far as we know, no more recent public overview exists.

The report also describes a Dutch case: a mid-sized insurer combined internal audit with compliance. DNB allowed this as an exception, partly because an external accountant carried out an internal audit of the compliance function. According to the same report, DNB had already told the market while preparing for Solvency II that it did not favour such a combination. For insurers that still combine the functions, 30 January 2027 therefore mainly marks the end of an exception.

What does this ask of the management board and supervisory board?

The first question is simple: who holds which key function as at 30 January 2027, and does the holder of the internal audit function hold any other function as well? If so, choices follow that take time.

If the current holder remains responsible for internal audit and hands over Risk Management, compliance or the actuarial function, a new name in the organisation chart is not enough. Under Standard 2.2 of the Global Internal Audit Standards, objectivity is presumed to be impaired when an auditor provides assurance on an activity for which that auditor was responsible within the previous twelve months. This applies to every key function the holder hands over. If the function follows the Standards, the transition calls for additional safeguards. An obvious solution is an external party that provides assurance on the transferred function during those twelve months. Standard 7.1 sets out the same solution for a temporary additional role of the head of internal audit: assurance by an independent third party during that role and for the twelve months after it.

If the insurer appoints a new holder, that person must be fit and proper (Article 42 of Solvency II). The revised Directive also requires insurers to notify the supervisor of changes in the persons who hold key functions. Where performance is outsourced in whole or in part, the insurer remains fully responsible under Article 49, and outsourcing of critical or important functions is notified to the supervisor in advance.

The documentation moves with it: the written internal audit policy, the Internal Audit Charter with the reporting lines to the management board and audit committee, and the audit plan. That plan covers several years and all activities and the complete system of governance (Article 271(3) of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35).

Where does this separation come from?

The separation is in line with what already applied to other financial institutions. At banks the audit function is combined with no other function, at pension funds not with another key function. Outside the financial sector, the trade-off remains with the organisation itself. In the Internal Audit Monitor 2021, which ONE Risk Advisory wrote with Nyenrode Business University at the request of the Institute of Internal Auditors Netherlands (IIA Netherlands), the conclusion on combining internal audit and Risk Management at listed companies was: no taboo, but conditions apply. For insurers, the legislator has made that trade-off from 30 January 2027.

How does ONE Risk Advisory support this?

We support the choices that come with a new set-up. Through Internal Audit Support we help set up or recalibrate the internal audit function, with the charter, audit universe, risk-based audit planning and the reporting lines to the management board and audit committee, and we provide senior capacity through co-sourcing or outsourcing. Through Governance & Control Design we organise roles and responsibilities in line with the Three Lines Model. We can also provide independent assurance on the transferred key function during the twelve months after the separation.

About ONE Risk Advisory

ONE Risk Advisory is a specialised firm for Risk Management and Internal Audit. We help organisations strengthen risk control, with engagements led by senior specialists.

We would be pleased to discuss the set-up in your organisation. Schedule a meeting.

Frequently asked questions

May an insurer still combine the internal audit function with Risk Management or compliance after 30 January 2027?

No. With effect from 30 January 2027, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/269 deletes the exception in Article 271(2) of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35. The persons carrying out the internal audit function may then no longer assume responsibility for any other function. The new Article 41(2a) of Solvency II also requires different persons for the four key functions.

Does the exception for small and non-complex undertakings also apply to internal audit?

No. Small and non-complex undertakings, and other insurers with prior approval from DNB, may combine Risk Management, the actuarial function and compliance under conditions. The internal audit function is excluded from this; DNB confirms it in its questions and answers on proportionality of 28 September 2026.

How many insurers currently combine the internal audit function with another key function?

No current figure is public. In the EIOPA peer review of November 2018, with 2016 as the reference year, supervisors in 15 countries, including the Netherlands, reported such combinations, generally at less than 5 per cent of insurers in a country and most often with compliance. No cases were found at large insurers.

Which safeguards fit when the internal audit function holder hands over another key function?

Under Standard 2.2 of the Global Internal Audit Standards, objectivity is presumed to be impaired when an auditor provides assurance on an activity for which the auditor was responsible within the previous twelve months. This applies to Risk Management, compliance and the actuarial function. An obvious safeguard is an external party that provides assurance on the transferred function during those twelve months.

What if the Dutch bill has not been adopted by 30 January 2027?

For the internal audit function, that makes no difference. A delegated regulation applies directly, so from 30 January 2027 Article 271 applies without the exception in its second paragraph, even if bill 37 007 is still pending.

May an insurer outsource the internal audit function?

Yes, Solvency II permits outsourcing. Under Article 49 the insurer remains fully responsible, and outsourcing of critical or important functions or activities is notified to the supervisor in advance.

Does the same apply to pension funds?

At pension funds the separation already applied. Under Article 24(2) of IORP II and Article 22c of the Dutch Financial Assessment Framework Decree (Besluit FTK), the internal audit function cannot be combined with another key function. Risk Management and the actuarial function may be combined with each other, except in the case of the certifying actuary.